Clutter Making You Crazy? How to Tell If You’re a Hoarder
Clutter can have an impact on both your mental and physical health, but it doesn’t have to. Use these tips to help you take control, and find out when it becomes a hoarding problem.
Oh, clutter. You make us crazy. You hide our important paperwork under junk mail. You make our soup disappear on refrigerator shelves behind cartons and containers. You fill our closets and drawers with junk.
Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy
If a problem with clutter seems overwhelming, don’t despair. The good news is that you can actually improve your health by getting rid of clutter — and it’s easier than you think.
“Clutter and hoarding behavior are very common problems,” says clinical psychologist Scott Bea, PsyD. Part of the problem is cultural: We live in a society that’s driven by consumerism, and many people amass things that they don’t need simply because acquiring stuff is what Americans do, he says.
Whether you feel like you must have the latest trends, engage in “retail therapy” to cheer yourself up, or succumb to persuasive advertising, you may end up with a house full of items of questionable use.
And because our culture is so focused on acquiring things, many of us have trouble recognizing when we have enough — or too much.
The word clutter actually comes from the middle English word “clotter.” You might say it can clot the flow of life, stopping you from using what you have, and making it hard to identify what you really need.
“Making decisions about ‘What do I do with this item now?’ is sometimes difficult,” Dr. Bea says. “Some people feel extremely stressed by this dilemma.”
If you struggle to make decisions about what to do with an object once you’re done with it, you might escape the tense situation by just not deciding. Once you get into a habit of this, things start to pile up, and before you know it, there’s a clutter problem.
Dr. Bea identifies a number of thoughts that people often have that can lead to indecision, including:
The more you struggle with these thoughts, the more likely you are to have a clutter problem.
Clutter can impact your health in many ways, and some of them might surprise you. Clutter can cause you to be:
Here are some ways to cope with clutter and get it out of your life:
Enlist some help. “Getting some outside assistance to help with the decision-making process is one of the most effective ways to overcome the stress associated with clutter,” says Dr. Bea. This might be a family member, friend, or paid decluttering consultant.
This is effective because your helper won’t experience the same high levels of tension associated with making tough decisions and discarding items, which can make the process faster and less stressful.
Set some rules. Especially if you’re going it alone, it helps to set some guidelines for yourself, and then stick to them. You may decide, “I need to throw out all magazines dated earlier than 2016” or “If I have not worn it in the last two years, it has to go.”
Break it down. If your clutter problem affects your whole home, it’s unrealistic to expect that you’re going to resolve it in a day or two. Instead, find some way to break the task into smaller parts.
You may decide to go room by room, or focus on particular categories — dealing with all clothing in the house, or all the books, for instance.
Have a plan. Many decluttering experts advocate sorting items into three piles: Keep, Donate, and Trash.
Make sure that at the end of each decluttering session you put away the items you’re keeping and put the stuff you’re throwing out in the trash. If possible, take donations immediately to their destination, or at least schedule a time to do so.
It’s a matter of severity. If your clutter is making it difficult for you or others to lead a normal lifestyle, or if it’s creating unhealthy living conditions, you may have a problem with hoarding.
“Individuals with hoarding problems rarely seek help on their own,” says Dr. Bea. “It is often a family member concerned or frustrated by the hoarding that compels the person to treatment.”
People with hoarding problems often have strong rationalizations to support their problematic habits. “Folks with clutter are less likely to defend themselves so strongly,” says Dr. Bea. In other words, if you’re able to identify that your clutter is a problem, you’re probably not a hoarder.