Should You Pay More for Cage-Free or Organic Eggs?

Egg labels aren't all they're cracked up to be

Should You Pay More for Cage-Free or Organic Eggs?

We spend all this extra money to buy eggs from the best sources, but it’s hard to be sure about their quality.

Advertising Policy

Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

One reason is because the labeling on egg cartons is bewildering. There are so many terms. Try to look them up on the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) or Department of Agriculture (USDA) websites, and you’ll find lengthy, confusing or loose definitions.

Don’t get me wrong – egg labels can be helpful and effective. Some tell you what the hens were fed. Others tell you a bit about their environment. Still others tell you how humanely they were raised.

But you need to know what to look for. Here is what the most common labels mean — and don’t mean.

USDA labels are sometimes useful

Organic: This means that hens received organic feed and were not raised in cages. When you eat organic eggs, you know the hens’ feed did not contain animal byproducts, synthetic fertilizers, sewage sludge, most pesticides, and other unsavory ingredients. Although antibiotics are rarely used in the egg industry, due to a regulatory loophole, it’s possible that organic eggs could come from hens given antibiotics. It’s worth checking into; although growth hormones are banned in poultry, antibiotics are not.

Also, an organic label says nothing about humane treatment. Hens’ outdoor access may be very limited, for example.

Advertising Policy

Omega-3 enriched: Egg yolks contain a small amount of omega-3, a heart-healthy fat. However, providing hens a diet high in omega-3, such as flaxseed or fish oil, can boost the omega-3 content in their eggs. However, according to the FDA, claims that omega-3 enriched eggs lower the risk of heart disease are unfounded, because eggs also contain cholesterol and saturated fat.

Free-range or free-roaming: This means that the hens producing the eggs were raised outdoors or given outdoor access. In addition to eating grains, these hens may forage for wild plants and insects. But the quality of the outdoor area, and how often the hens can access it, is not addressed. Hens living in crowded quarters may not budge when a farmer opens the doors once a day.

Cage-free: “Cage-free” is not analogous to “free-range.” It simply means that hens are not bound by cages and have unlimited access to food and water. Conditions on cage-free farms can be miserable. Overcrowded barns and poultry houses don’t give hens enough room to forage for plants and insects or dust-bathe. A new egg label, “barn-roaming,” may better describe those from hens confined to barns.

Third-party labels are more helpful

Animal welfare approved (AWA): If you want your eggs to come from happy chickens, this is considered the gold standard. AWA deals only with family farms and has the strictest criteria for hens’ ability to live in their natural state. Farmers focus on promoting hens’ health and well-being rather than on treating diseases. Because this label combines organic feeding with humane living conditions and handling, you’ve covered all your bases.

Certified humane: If you can’t find AWA eggs where you live, look for eggs certified by Humane Farm Animal Care. This nonprofit organization inspects egg farms yearly to ensure that hens live unconfined, with enough room to nest, perch, take dust baths, etc. Hens have unlimited access to fresh water and wholesome feed, and benefit from humane handling.

Advertising Policy

If it’s hard to find AWA or certified humane eggs, I suggest you get to know farmers within a 25-mile radius of your house. Five to 10 years ago, that would have been hard, but no more. You can meet them at your local farmer’s market. Ask if you can visit their farm, and go out and check out their chicken coops. If they say no, that’s a red flag.

My egg farmer lives two blocks away, and I can see his wonderful chickens hanging out in his backyard.

You can also look into community supported agriculture, and have all your eggs delivered to your door from one farmer you trust. It’s easy to find CSAs near you.

Or here’s an idea: buy your own chickens and a coop, and collect your own fresh eggs every day.

Advertising Policy
Kristin Kirkpatrick, MS, RD, LD

Kristin Kirkpatrick, MS, RD, LD

Kristin Kirkpatrick, MS, RD, LD, is a registered dietitian and wellness manager for the Cleveland Clinic Wellness Institute.
Advertising Policy