December 12, 2022/Weight Loss

Who Should Consider Bariatric Surgery?

A safe and effective surgery that shouldn’t be considered only as a last resort

woman on scale weight loss bariatric diet

Having obesity is more than a number on a scale or a measurement of your body mass index (BMI). It’s a complex metabolic disease.

Advertisement

Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

When you’re living with obesity, your metabolism slows. That means, even with big changes in your diet or exercise habits, your body may not react. And your weight may not reflect the efforts you’re making.

Bariatric surgery, or what some people may call weight loss surgery, can counteract that metabolic change if you have obesity.

“Bariatric surgery is an important and effective treatment for people living with obesity to manage their health,” says bariatric surgeon Ali Aminian, MD. “We know that the body responds to weight loss surgery in many ways that help people with obesity to manage their conditions and live full lives.”

Bariatric surgery is a safe, evidence-based treatment that does more for your body than shed pounds. Dr. Aminian says it’s the #1 most effective route to treating obesity and obesity-related illnesses. Better than any diet or exercise program.

We talked with Dr. Aminian about what you need to know about bariatric surgery so you can decide if you might be a candidate.

What is bariatric surgery?

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimates that more than 42% of people in the U.S. have obesity. But only about 1% of people who are eligible actually get bariatric surgery.

Bariatric surgery has been shown to:

  • Lower the risk of developing obesity-related cancers.
  • Decrease the risk of progression of fatty liver disease to cirrhosis.
  • Provide significant protective effects for future heart attacks or stroke.
  • Lessen the severity of COVID-19 infection.
  • Lead to long-term remission of Type 2 diabetes.

In the past, bariatric surgery was a more invasive procedure. Following surgery, people would stay in the hospital for up to a week. Recovery would take several months.

These days, most bariatric surgeries are done laparoscopically. That’s to say, they’re minimally invasive surgeries that use a thin, telescopic rod with a camera at the end to see inside your body. That means quicker recoveries and fewer complications.

“We do surgery through five or six small holes,” Dr. Aminian explains. “People go home the same day or the next day, and they recover after two or three days. Today’s procedures are much safer and produce better effects to help people lose weight and lower their risk for obesity-related illnesses.”

Two popular laparoscopic procedures — Roux-en-Y Gastric Bypass and sleeve gastrectomy — now account for about 90% of all weight-loss surgeries performed worldwide.

Here, Dr. Aminian answers some common questions people have about bariatric surgery.

Q: Who is a candidate for bariatric surgery?

A: There are two leading authorities on bariatric surgery: The American Society for Metabolic and Bariatric Surgery (ASMBS)and the International Federation for the Surgery of Obesity and Metabolic Disorders (IFSO). The two organizations published their latest guidelines in 2022. They recommend bariatric surgery be considered for:

  1. Adults who have a BMI of 35 or higher (class II obesity).
  2. Adults with a BMI of 30 to 35 (class I obesity) who also have Type 2 diabetes.
  3. Adults with a BMI of 30 to 35 who haven’t been able to achieve “substantial or durable weight loss or obesity disease-related improvement” by other means.
  4. Children and adolescents who are living with a BMI of 40 or higher (class III obesity).
  5. Children and adolescents with class II obesity and a major obesity-related condition.

Advertisement

This is an expansion of previous guidelines published in the early 1990s. Those guidelines suggested bariatric surgery be reserved for people with more severe forms of obesity.

Dr. Aminian hopes the expanded guidelines will help more people access bariatric surgery and its benefits.

“The field of metabolic and bariatric surgery has progressed considerably,” Dr. Aminian adds. “I hope these guidelines can open the doors for some people who did not have access to bariatric and metabolic surgery by the old, outdated guidelines.”

Q: Is bariatric surgery safe?

A: Research shows bariatric surgery is as safe or safer than many other routine surgeries, like gallbladder removals, appendix removals and knee replacements. It’s been around decades now, since the 1970s, and the latest techniques have proven to have few complications.

Advertisement

Especially when you consider the long-term risks of living with obesity, any risk of bariatric surgery is very minimal.

Q: Is bariatric surgery effective?

A: Bariatric surgery has helped millions of people treat obesity and related conditions.

“Bariatric surgery is currently the most effective tool we have to improve the lives and the health of people living with obesity,” Dr. Aminian states. “After bariatric surgery, people typically lose 20% to 40% of their body weight and sustain it over decades. On average, bariatric surgery can provide six years of additional life for people with obesity.”

Q: Is bariatric surgery a last resort?

A: You may have heard bariatric surgery mentioned as a sort of backup method to other obesity treatments, like diet and exercise. But Dr. Aminian encourages a change in that thinking.

“For people with heart disease, we don’t wait to treat them until they experience a heart attack. For people with cancer, it is always better to start treatment in the earliest stage. A similar concept is true when we consider weight-loss surgery to treat obesity,” Dr. Aminian stresses. “Surgery shouldn’t be viewed as the last resort or only for patients with extremely high BMIs.”

In other words, it’s safer and more effective to intervene when obesity is in its earlier stages, rather than waiting until you experience severe complications.

A note about BMI

You’ll notice that the guidelines for people who are candidates for bariatric surgery use BMI as a benchmark for determining eligibility. BMI is a measurement of your height-to-weight ratio.

The truth is that BMI is not an entirely accurate measurement of your health, though. That’s because muscle weighs more than fat. So, people who are more muscular tend to have a higher BMI, but that doesn‘t mean they’re less healthy.

“BMI has its limitations,” Dr. Aminian notes. “In the future, it’s likely that we will have a better understanding of the disease process, which will allow us to take a more individualized approach to treatment. But for now, treating people based on certain BMI thresholds is the most practical way to address obesity.”

Your healthcare provider will consider your BMI as one indication of your health, but it shouldn’t be the only factor considered. Your provider will be able to help you understand if your BMI is a true reflection of a health concern or not.

The truth about treating obesity

More than 650 million adults around the world were living with obesity in 2016, according to the World Health Organization. In the United States, the prevalence of obesity increased from about 31% to 42% between 2000 and 2017. It’s estimated that by 2030, 50% of people in the U.S. will be living with obesity. Estimates show that 1 in 4 of them will have class III obesity.

“The biggest issue is that we overly emphasize lifestyle modifications,” Dr. Aminian says. “Obesity is a chronic progressive disease. It requires more aggressive treatment.”

If you’re living with obesity, talk with a healthcare provider about whether you might be a candidate for bariatric surgery. They can help you understand your options.

Advertisement

Learn more about our editorial process.

Related Articles

Person eating tiny amount of bland food, daydreaming about larger portion of better food, amidst silhouette of crowd eating
April 19, 2024/Mental Health
The Intersection of Obesity and Eating Disorders

Having overweight and disordered eating is a high-risk combination that often gets dismissed or overlooked

Doctor shaking hands with patient, with large heart and EKG line behind them
February 19, 2024/Heart Health
How Weight Affects Your Heart

Having underweight, having overweight and having obesity can be dangerous for your heart

Two bariatric surgery options: grastric bypass and gastric sleeve
February 14, 2024/Digestive
How To Know Which Type of Bariatric Surgery Is Right for You

Gastric bypass and sleeve gastrectomy are different procedures that offer similar benefits, including significant weight loss

Showing self injection of mounjaro into thigh.
October 24, 2023/Weight Loss
How Mounjaro Is Helping People With Obesity Lose Weight

This diabetes drug is quickly gaining attention for weight loss potential

Weight scale with arrow pointing to overweight is shown with sneakers and a water bottle in foreground.
September 10, 2023/Diet, Food & Fitness
Is It Healthy To Be ‘Fat and Fit’?

Having obesity brings long-term health risks no matter your fitness level

Person handing a pharmacist a prescription.
March 29, 2023/Weight Loss
Is Ozempic the Answer for Your Weight Loss?

This diabetes med can treat obesity, but it’s not for people who just want to drop a few pounds

Variety of weight loss drugs.
January 16, 2023/Weight Loss
The New Anti-Obesity Drugs: What You Should Know

You can lose 15% of your body weight, plus lower your heart disease and diabetes risks

Different people on beach with a variety of body shapes.
January 13, 2023/Wellness
What Does Your Body Shape Say About Your Health?

Any body shape can be a healthy one, but a thicker midsection can be a red flag

Trending Topics

Person in yellow tshirt and blue jeans relaxing on green couch in living room reading texts on their phone.
Here’s How Many Calories You Naturally Burn in a Day

Your metabolism may torch 1,300 to 2,000 calories daily with no activity

woman snacking on raisins and nuts
52 Foods High In Iron

Pump up your iron intake with foods like tuna, tofu and turkey

Ad