We’ve all heard that slow and steady wins the race. But when you want to lose weight quickly, patience (and sometimes, even common sense) can fly out the window.
Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy
We know that living at a healthy weight is good for our bodies. And, frankly, losing a few pounds can be a boost to our self-image.
But if you’re looking for a quick-fix diet to lose 10 pounds in a week, you’re probably barking up the wrong tree.
“Sure, it’s going to be possible to lose significant weight quickly, but when you understand what that does to your body, you’ll see that it’s probably not a good idea,” says endocrinologist and obesity specialist Marcio Griebeler, MD. “It’s not going to give you the results you’re actually looking for.”
What does quick weight loss do to your body? Dr. Griebeler breaks it down.
Yes, it’s entirely possible to lose 10 pounds in a week. But that doesn’t mean it’s a good idea or that it’s going to last.
Say you have a vacation coming up or a big event. Naturally, you want to look your best. Nothing wrong with that.
So, you follow the celebrity advice du jour for rapid weight loss. Maybe you eat only veggies for a week straight. Or you cut out all carbs and sugars. You kick your workout routine into hyper-drive.
Maybe it pans out. Maybe you really did lose those 10 pounds in a week. It’s certainly possible to do. But that weight loss is likely to be very short-lived.
Dr. Griebeler explains that’s because quick weight loss is often a result of losing not only fat, but also water and muscle mass. For weight loss to be successful and sustainable, you need to burn fat and preserve muscle. And that will take some time and dedication.
Often, our first go-to if we want to shed some pounds quickly is to significantly restrict our caloric intake (aka, crash diet). Cutting way back on calories for a short amount of time can have effects on your weight, sure. But it’s just not something you can do long-term.
“You’re not going to stay on a 500-calorie-a-day diet for very long,” Dr. Griebeler says. “It’s not sustainable. Your body needs fuel, and it will adapt to keep you from keeping that kind of diet up for long.”
So, after dieting for seven days and dropping those 10 pounds, what are you left with? An insatiable appetite. Low energy. Weakness. All in all: A perfect storm that will lead to eating more and exercising less.
So, what happens? Those 10 pounds you dropped are now right back where they started.
Cardio exercises are great for cardiovascular fitness and an important part of a healthy lifestyle. The American Heart Association recommends we get at least 150 minutes of moderate-intensity exercise per week (or 75 minutes per week if you do more vigorous aerobic activity).
So, yes, your favorite cardio exercises — like running, ellipticals, cycling and so on — are a great way to get your heart pumping and burn off serious calories.
But in order to effectively perform cardio exercise, we have to provide the body with energy.
“You need to replenish those calories that you’re losing from exercise. Your body will be begging for them — incessantly,” Dr. Griebeler states. “If you don’t eat, you’re going to be tired, and, therefore, you’re not going to be able to keep up all that exercise.”
Dr. Griebeler says that’s because building muscle helps improve your body composition and improves your metabolic rate. Strengthening exercises increase muscle and decrease fat, which is a very healthy and good thing for your body. More muscle actually helps your body burn more energy at rest. So, no doubt, strengthening is a good thing.
But for quick weight loss? Not so much.
Muscle weighs more than fat. So, if you’re looking to lose weight fast, extra strengthening isn’t going to do it. (Though, as Dr. Griebeler points out, your body composition is a better indication of your health than the number on your bathroom scale.)
What’s more is that building muscle takes time. More than a week. And here’s the rub — in order to build muscle, your body needs energy. It needs you to bring in the calories. That’s why bodybuilders are always pounding those protein shakes. So, you won’t build muscle when you’re also restricting calories.
It’s not the advice you wanted to hear, but sustainable weight loss takes time. That’s just the plain truth of it. It takes time for your body to adjust to your new routines and get comfortable with the idea of weight loss.
Quick weight loss is a signal to your body that you’re starving. So, it fights back.
Gradual weight loss allows your body to get comfortable with a new normal. It’s a signal that all is well. That you got this handled. So, your body lets you take control.
The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommends that you aim for losing one to two pounds per week.
Dr. Griebeler says that’s because gradual weight loss gives your body a chance to adapt. But even with that guidance, everybody will respond to weight loss a little differently, so even if one to two pounds per week is the general goal, your weight loss may look different from that. And that’s OK.
Remember, too, that your weight is only one side of the coin. Losing fat should be the real goal. And that can be done without the number on the scale budging.
“If you’re building muscle, you’ll be burning fat, even though your weight is the same or even if it goes up a bit,” Dr. Griebeler says. “If you have more muscle, I can guarantee you your metabolic rate is up and you’re burning fat. And you’ll be overall healthier, regardless of whether you’ve hit that weight number that you’re looking for.”
He also offers these quick tips for lasting weight loss:
If you’re living with obesity (a BMI of 30 or higher), though, your body may be less likely to respond to these tactics, Dr. Griebeler notes. That’s because obesity is a metabolic disorder that can keep you from losing weight and keeping it off, even when you go gradually. If you’re living with obesity, talk with a provider about options like anti-obesity medication.