The advice dates to 1574, but it falls a little short given what we know today
Image content: This image is available to view online.
View image online (https://assets.clevelandclinic.org/transform/7a2f5b68-7e0e-42df-b60a-628880ea63c0/feed-cold-starve-fever-2184582488)
Person sick on couch, with hot soup and tea, meds and tissues on table nearby
At one time, “feed a cold, starve a fever” may have been cutting-edge medical advice.
Advertisement
Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy
This nugget of health wisdom traces back to a dictionary compiled in 1574 by English lexicographer John Withals. His guidance — “fasting is a great remedy of fever” — has certainly stood the test of time as an oft-quoted rule.
But does it match medical guidance in the 21st century? Let’s find out from family physician Simon Hodes, MB ChB.
The easy-to-remember phrase offers basic care steps for when you’re sick. It matches old beliefs and theories that suggested:
The reasoning revolves around something called diet-induced thermogenesis. That’s the scientific term describing how your body warms after eating, as your metabolism fires up to digest food.
If a cold gives you the chills, logic dictates that some internal “heating” from eating warm food would be welcome. On the flip side, getting hotter after eating a meal isn’t ideal if you’re already burning up with a temperature.
“Given that they had no reliable medicine to treat a fever in 1574, it’s understandable how someone reached those conclusions,” says Dr. Hodes.
Now, let’s take a closer look, using modern science.
Absolutely! Eating nutritious food can supercharge your immune system as it fights off illness. It’s also important to take in enough food and fluids to maintain your energy and hydration levels.
Advertisement
“If you’re feeling up to it, you should try to eat and drink as you normally would,” says Dr. Hodes. “Be guided by your appetite.”
Absolutely NOT! Starving yourself is never a great idea — and that’s especially true if you’re feeling unwell. If anything, in that situation, you should focus on taking in enough calories and lots of fluids.
That’s because a fever speeds up your metabolism while also cranking up your internal temperature. That stoked furnace makes you burn more calories and lose fluids — which makes replenishing them critical.
“This is not the time to intentionally cut back,” stresses Dr. Hodes.
Drinking enough fluids is especially important in this situation, as your overheated body can leave you dehydrated. “The main thing during any illness is to drink plenty of fluids,” he adds.
The traditional bowl of chicken soup or even plain broth remains the gold standard when it comes to eating while sick, says Dr. Hodes. (That wisdom dates back to ancient times, by the way.)
So, why is chicken soup or broth so good for you when you’re sick? For starters, the liquid-based meals work to prevent dehydration. They’re loaded with nutrients and antioxidants that can help you get well, too.
Advertisement
Adding chicken to the soup brings protein and iron to boost your immune system, and any healthy veggies thrown into the pot are … well, just naturally healthy to eat.
Plus, soup’s soothing warmth and steam can help ease a sore throat and loosen up any mucus.
“Chicken soup or broth just makes you feel better,” says Dr. Hodes. “Even if you’re not feeling too hungry, some small sips can provide you with both fluid and nutrition in one go.”
Other food and drink to seek out when sick include:
It’s no secret that a cold or fever can wipe away your appetite. If you’re not able to eat your normal meals for a few days, don’t worry too much. But again, do focus on drinking plenty of fluids.
“Many of us aren’t living on the edge of nutrition,” recognizes Dr. Hodes. “We’ve got plenty of reserves if we lose our appetite for a few days. But try to get in what you can and definitely make sure to keep your fluid intake up.”
Advertisement
But if your appetite doesn’t return after a few days, contact a healthcare provider. You should also connect with your doctor if your condition worsens. Concerning symptoms include:
“If things don’t seem right or you’re ever in doubt about what to do next for you or your child, it’s time to contact someone for advice,” states Dr. Hodes. “Basically, if in doubt, check it out.”
There is some sound logic behind the advice offered by Withals in 1574, but today, we know that the well-meaning adage wasn’t quite accurate. But with a little modification, it can still be helpful.
“Maybe we should just say ‘feed a cold and a fever — and make sure to drink enough, too,’” suggests Dr. Hodes. “Your body needs resources when you’re sick. Try to make sure it gets them.”
Advertisement
Sign up for our Health Essentials emails for expert guidance on nutrition, fitness, sleep, skin care and more.
Learn more about our editorial process.
Advertisement
Viruses cause common colds, so antibiotics won’t help
From poor hand hygiene and ventilation issues to contaminated food, many factors can make infectious diseases spread quickly
They’re viral cousins, but enteroviruses are more likely to cause serious illness
You can’t cure a cold, but these simple home remedies can help you feel better faster
Don’t expect miracles out of ‘immune-boosting’ supplements when you’re sick
Sinus infections tend to last longer and include symptoms like facial pressure and discolored mucus
Enteroviruses are often to blame for summer colds, leading to a runny nose, sore throat and digestive symptoms
Stress and unhealthy habits can lead to more colds, but taking some precautions may help you stay well
Research hints at improved strength, balance, blood flow and weight loss, but more evidence is needed
The blended oat beverage may help curb hunger, but it doesn’t work like a GLP-1
Teen cycles are often ‘off-cycle’ for the first few years