Advertisement
The nocebo effect is a phenomenon where expectations of negative outcomes may influence the results
You’ve probably heard of the placebo effect. That’s the idea that people can be more likely to experience a benefit from a medication or other intervention if they expect it to help. Even if it’s not a valid treatment.
Advertisement
Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy
But there’s another side to the placebo effect. A kind of evil twin, you might say.
It’s called the nocebo effect. And it can also impact how you experience the effects of medical interventions. But for the worse.
What’s the nocebo effect? And what does it mean for your health? We talked with wellness and preventive medicine physician Robert Saper, MD, about it.
The nocebo effect is a phenomenon where people experience very real negative effects from a medical intervention if that’s what they expect going in. It’s all about the power of suggestion.
For example, if you’re rolling up your sleeve for your annual flu vaccine and the nurse tells you, “This is going to hurt.” Chances are, it’s going to hurt. A lot.
If they tell you, “You might feel a quick prick, but it goes away fast.” You can be more likely to report that it wasn’t so bad.
The nocebo effect is an example of how our minds and bodies work together — that our thoughts and feelings can influence our physical well-being.
That’s not to say that the nocebo effect (or the placebo effect for that matter) is all in your head.
But as Dr. Saper points out, “It’s not all in your body either. There’s a strong mind-body connection. The input we get from our bodies travels up neurons to the brain. The brain has complex ways of processing that information. For example, when we’re experiencing pain, the brain has the capacity to send information down to the body that can mitigate the sensation of pain. Or it can amplify it.”
Advertisement
And the effects go far beyond pain. Think about that “butterflies in your belly” feeling when you get nervous. Or how you may tremble when you’re scared. Or how your face gets hot when you’re angry.
Your thoughts, feelings and emotions very directly affect your physical self. And negative expectations can influence your perception of the effects.
The placebo effect describes how people can have a positive outcome that wouldn’t, scientifically, be expected.
Like sugar pills improving your headache. Or, according to some studies, improving stretch marks with cocoa butter.
The nocebo effect says that you can have a bad experience with a particular intervention or event, if that’s what you expect to happen.
“With the placebo effect, we see people gaining a benefit from an intervention, even if there’s no scientific reason for that benefit to occur,” Dr. Saper explains. “The nocebo effect works in a similar way, but with negative consequences.”
In both the placebo and nocebo effect, the expectation of what you’ll experience affects how you perceive the experience.
Placebo effect | Nocebo effect | |
---|---|---|
Expectation | This will improve my migraine. | This will make my migraine worse. |
Effect | You feel better. | You feel worse. |
Expectation | ||
Placebo effect | ||
This will improve my migraine. | ||
Nocebo effect | ||
This will make my migraine worse. | ||
Effect | ||
Placebo effect | ||
You feel better. | ||
Nocebo effect | ||
You feel worse. |
Examples of the nocebo effect are all around us.
If you drink a cup of coffee late in the day, you may have a harder time falling asleep. Even if the brew is decaf.
If a friend advises against going to a particular restaurant because they didn’t like their meal there, you can be less likely to enjoy yours.
If the weather forecaster emphasizes the drastic cold front bearing down on your area, you might feel the chill more acutely — even through your parka, hat, scarf, mittens and snow boots.
In medical contexts, the nocebo effect is in full force, too:
Even the way a healthcare provider shares information with you can raise the possibility of the nocebo effect.
“If, for example, you go to a doctor and ask about a treatment and they say, ‘Well, I don't think it's going to help you, but I suppose you could try it,’ not only will you lose any potential placebo effect, but it may even have a negative outcome,” Dr. Saper shares.
Advertisement
“On the other hand, if I suggest a treatment with a fair amount of hope and optimism attached to that recommendation, you might be more likely to have a better experience with it.”
Let’s be clear: Medical interventions can have side effects. There can be pain. They may not be effective. And they can be tough to manage.
No one is arguing that negative effects can’t happen.
But knowing that the nocebo effect exists can give you a reason to look more critically at the potential for a connection between your expectations and the effects they have on your well-being.
Say you hurt your back shoveling the driveway. Your doctor recommends physical therapy. But you tried that a few years ago for your knee and it didn’t work.
So, you assume that PT won’t work for your hip either. You go. But (no surprise to you) your hip still hurts. Now you’re looking at surgery.
If you had higher expectations of therapy, perhaps it may have been more successful. And you could have avoided a more invasive procedure. Maybe not. But maybe so.
Or maybe you have high blood pressure. And you blame your blood pressure medication for upsetting your stomach. So, you stop taking the meds. That’s a recipe for unmanaged hypertension, which can do serious damage throughout your body.
Advertisement
But was the nausea really a result of taking the medication? Might there be something else at play? It’s tough to say. But worth considering.
“Our minds and bodies have some potential to improve or, conversely, worsen some types of symptoms. In some instances, that potential can be harvested for good use,” Dr. Saper affirms. “And that can be empowering to understand and use to your benefit.”
Advertisement
Learn more about our editorial process.
Advertisement
You can alternate these OTCs to help with pain management and fever reduction
They’re fun to watch, but medical TV shows are often more hype than reality — and you shouldn’t rely on them for factual medical information
This purple perennial has many uses, including sleep hygiene, reducing inflammation and pain, and elevating mood
Irritation from skin rubbing against skin or clothes can affect your whole body, but powders, creams and even the right underwear can help protect you
Make your home a no-fly zone by cleaning your drains, refrigerating your produce and DIYing a fruit fly trap
Taking supplements with biotin can cause inaccurate lab test results
The answer depends on both dosage and drinking habits
Always seek medical advice for pain — but exercise, stretching, guided imagery and deep breathing may help in the meantime
Not all ear infections need antibiotics — cold and warm compresses and changing up your sleep position can help
A glass of lemon water in the morning can help with digestion and boost vitamin C levels, and may even help get you into a better routine