Both can cause bleeding, irritation and pain, but you shouldn’t try to tell them apart on your own
Image content: This image is available to view online.
View image online (https://assets.clevelandclinic.org/transform/ec76fdaf-19ea-4722-b9c8-9b85536fc59f/doctor-patient-discuss-test-results-1343539360)
Person talking with a healthcare provider and reviewing information on a sheet of paper
If you notice pain, itching or bleeding around your anus, it’s natural to assume you’re dealing with hemorrhoids — and in many cases, you are. Hemorrhoids are common, uncomfortable and usually harmless.
Advertisement
Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy
But in some cases, symptoms that seem like hemorrhoids can actually be a sign of anal cancer — a much rarer but serious condition that needs prompt treatment.
“Hemorrhoids and anal cancer affect the same general area, but they’re very different conditions,” says colorectal surgeon Scott R. Steele, MD, MBA. He explains what to know about each and when to seek care.
Hemorrhoids are swollen veins in or around your anus. Everyone has hemorrhoidal tissue. It only becomes a problem when those veins swell, stretch or become irritated.
“We actually all have hemorrhoids as a part of our normal anatomy,” Dr. Steele notes. “But when these veins overfill with blood, or they become lax or loose, they become troublesome. And that’s what we call hemorrhoidal disease.”
Anal cancer, on the other hand, starts when abnormal cells grow in the lining of the anal canal. It’s not related to hemorrhoids, but the symptoms can be similar.
If you’re wondering whether hemorrhoids can cause cancer, the answer is a definitive no.
“Hemorrhoids are not cancer, and they don’t turn into cancer,” Dr. Steele reassures.
Anal cancer and hemorrhoids can cause some of the same symptoms, like anal bleeding, discomfort and irritation, but there are often subtle differences. Hemorrhoids commonly cause:
Advertisement
“Bleeding is one of the most common problems we see with hemorrhoids,” Dr. Steele notes. “Hemorrhoids can also cause pain that can become quite debilitating. And they can secrete mucus that may make it hard for you to stay hygienic down there.”
Anal cancer may also cause pain and bleeding, but the symptoms present a little differently. They may include:
If you’re dealing with symptoms like anal pain and bleeding, don’t make assumptions about the cause.
Dr. Steele emphasizes that you can’t reliably tell the difference between hemorrhoids and anal cancer just by looking or guessing. A proper examination by a healthcare provider is important, especially if your symptoms don’t improve.
“The overlap in symptoms can lead people to delay care,” he points out. “Many people try to treat the problem themselves, assuming they’re dealing with hemorrhoids that will go away on their own.”
Hemorrhoids and anal cancer have very different causes. Hemorrhoids develop when pressure builds up in the veins around your anus, while anal cancer is linked to abnormal cell changes.
Common contributors to hemorrhoids include:
Dr. Steele says diet often plays an important role in hemorrhoids. It commonly comes down to fiber, which helps you poop.
“People who don’t consume enough fiber tend to be constipated and spend a lot of time on the toilet,” he adds. “When you strain on the toilet bowl to try to force a bowel movement, that often leads to hemorrhoidal disease.”
Anal cancer is caused by DNA changes in the cells. In particular, it’s linked to certain types of human papillomavirus (HPV) infection. But other factors may raise your risk, too, including immune system changes and having other types of cancer.
Hemorrhoids and anal cancer are also treated differently.
Hemorrhoid treatment often starts conservatively, with changes you can make to your diet and your pooping habits:
Advertisement
If dietary and lifestyle changes don’t do the trick, your provider may recommend a procedure, like rubber band ligation for internal hemorrhoids or surgery for the ones on the outside. But hemorrhoids often improve without the need for medical or surgical intervention.
Anal cancer, however, can’t be treated with lifestyle changes. Cancer treatment is more complex. It may include a combination of approaches like chemotherapy or radiation, depending on factors like the cancer stage and location.
“Care is typically coordinated by a colorectal and oncology team, with the goal of treating the cancer while preserving function,” Dr. Steele shares. “The earlier anal cancer is diagnosed, the more treatment options are usually available.”
If something doesn’t seem right, it’s always worth getting checked out.
“If you assume it’s hemorrhoids and it’s not, you lose valuable time waiting to get treatment if something more serious is going on,” stresses Dr. Steele. “An exam gives you clarity and peace of mind.”
Make an appointment with a healthcare provider if you have:
Advertisement
It’s understandable if you feel nervous or embarrassed to talk about such personal problems. But it’s important not to self-diagnose or cope in secret. Remember: Colorectal surgeons see these concerns every day, and treating them is their job.
“If anything has become troublesome, we recommend seeking medical intervention,” Dr. Steele urges. “Most commonly, it’s going to be hemorrhoids — but we don't ever want to take any chances.”
Advertisement
Sign up for our Health Essentials emails for expert guidance on nutrition, fitness, sleep, skin care and more.
Learn more about our editorial process.
Advertisement
That constant itch is common, but relief starts with understanding what’s causing the irritation
Your pooping habits, diet and fluid intake can all play a role in limiting painful hemorrhoid issues
Try sitting in a sitz bath or taking psyllium husk to help relieve symptoms
Unexpected DNA changes can cause cells to grow out of control and lead to cancer
No, we aren’t all born with cancer cells — and having cancer in your family doesn’t mean you already have cancer or will necessarily develop it
Viruses cause common colds, so antibiotics won’t help
Supporting your immune system starts with taking care of your overall health — from the foods you eat to your daily habits
The advice dates to 1574, but it falls a little short given what we know today
Research hints at improved strength, balance, blood flow and weight loss, but more evidence is needed
The blended oat beverage may help curb hunger, but it doesn’t work like a GLP-1
Teen cycles are often ‘off-cycle’ for the first few years