May 11, 2021

Better Than Butter? Separating Ghee Fact From Fiction

From improved digestion to weight loss, ghee’s claimed benefits are clarified

Glass container filled with a yellow, semi-solid substance with a spoonful taken out taken to it

Butter makes everything better — but does ghee count, too? The ancient form of butter is fast becoming a 21st-century staple. And some say ghee’s benefits aren’t just about flavor.

Advertisement

Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

“Some research has shown that people who consume ghee butter in traditional ways may have lower risks of heart disease,” says registered dietitian Candace O’Neill. “But in the ghee vs. butter debate, there’s a lot of misinformation out there about ghee being the better choice.”

What is ghee?

When you churn milk or cream long enough, it separates into two components: butterfat (solid) and buttermilk (liquid). Butter is the butterfat. Ghee takes this process a step further.

“Ghee is clarified butter, which means it’s heated to the point where manufacturers can remove any remaining water and caramelized milk solids. What’s left — the ghee — is fat that’s even more concentrated,” says O’Neill.

In traditional Indian and East Asian cooking, ghee has been a go-to for centuries. “It has a nuttier, richer taste than butter,” says O’Neill. “Many people also enjoy ghee because it has a higher smoke point (the temperature during cooking when the oil starts smoking) than butter.”

O’Neill recommends using ghee like butter. “But if you’re buying a jar of ghee from a grocery store, you may want to mix before using it because it can separate.”

Ghee vs. butter: Which fat reigns supreme?

While some tout ghee as butter’s healthier cousin, O’Neill says that ghee’s perceived benefits may be overblown. “There is no significant difference between the two. The fat and vitamin content is almost the same.”

Advertisement

O’Neill clarifies three common health claims about ghee butter.

Q. Is ghee dairy free?

A. It’s not dairy-free, though ghee may be a good choice for people who are lactose-intolerant. That’s because it contains extremely low levels of lactose and casein (a milk protein). But so does butter.

“Some people who avoid dairy for digestive reasons may tolerate ghee better than butter. But in general, they should be fine with butter as well because the amounts of lactose and casein are so small,” notes O’Neill. “If you have a casein allergy, you should definitely avoid consuming both in case of cross-contamination.”

Q. Is ghee better for digestion and colon health?

A. Dairy products contain a compound called butyrate, which is a type of short-chain fatty acid. Butyrate is the main energy source for the cells that line your colon and helps them regenerate. This process is important for colon health and digestion.

Some herald ghee as a rich source of butyrate, but O’Neill says not so fast. “Ghee has about 1% of butyrate, which is a tiny, insignificant amount compared to what your colon produces,” she says.

“You can also get a good amount of short-chain fatty acids from eating fiber-rich foods, such as fruits, vegetables, whole grains and legumes. These foods help your body ramp up the production of short-chain fatty acids. That’s the better way to improve colon health.”

Advertisement

Q. Is ghee good for weight loss?

A. It’s not hard to find a blog claiming ghee is a metabolism-booster. But what does science say?

“Ghee contains medium-chain triglyceride (MCT) oil, which some research suggests could help with weight loss. But it’s in trace amounts, so if you’re looking to get MCT oil in your diet, ghee’s not the best way to go,” says O’Neill. “Ghee and butter also have a compound called conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), which may help reduce fat mass. But again, ghee only has insignificant amounts of it.”

The bottom line?

O’Neill says choosing ghee should be a matter of personal preference and not based on any perceived health benefits. “The potential compounds that ghee contains are not significant enough to improve your health.”

Related Articles

recipe: compound butter with herbs
February 22, 2021
Recipe: Compound Butter With Fresh Herbs

Use this good-quality fat to enhance the flavor of your meat dishes

Butter on Toast
August 2, 2020
What You Should Know About Cholesterol and Butter

The creamy cooking ingredient is delicious but not without its risks

Hand holding an artichoke over a basket of artichokes
February 23, 2024
10 Health Benefits of Artichokes

This unique-looking veggie is fiber-dense and antioxidant-rich, and can improve the health of your gut, liver and heart

overhead photograph of open and empty energy drinks
February 19, 2024
Are Energy Drinks Bad for You?

Regularly drinking these sugar-fueled, stimulant-laden beverages can increase your risk of adverse health effects

Pouring a homemade spinach and banana smoothie into a glass
February 16, 2024
7 Reasons You Should Eat More Spinach

Vitamin-packed and antioxidant-rich, spinach can benefit your brain, eyes, blood and more

Older couple eating lunch on outdoor patio
February 15, 2024
Calories and Aging: Cutting Back Can Slow Age’s Creep

Calorie reduction can do more than just help you lose weight — it can also lower age-related inflammation

Various cuts of red meat displayed
February 14, 2024
Is Red Meat Bad for You?

It has nutrients your body needs, but it also comes with some serious health risks

A roasted pork chop on a mound of vegetables with sauce, displayed in a white bowl
February 12, 2024
Is Pork Red or White Meat? And Is It Healthy?

Despite what you may have heard, pork is actually red meat (and it comes with the same risks as other red meats)

Trending Topics

close up of keto gummies
Do Keto Gummies Work for Weight Loss? Are They Safe?

Research is inconclusive whether or not these supplements are helpful

Person in yellow tshirt and blue jeans relaxing on green couch in living room reading texts on their phone.
Here’s How Many Calories You Naturally Burn in a Day

Your metabolism may torch 1,300 to 2,000 calories daily with no activity

Older person postioned sideways showing dowager hump.
Dowager’s Hump: What It Is and How To Get Rid of It

The hump at the base of your neck may be caused by osteoporosis or poor posture

Ad