Skin Tag Removal: Why You Shouldn’t DIY

Spoiler alert — it could lead to an infection
Skin tag

You’re putting on your favorite necklace and it gets caught on a tiny, rogue flap of skin that’s popped up right at your neckline. Sound familiar?

Advertising Policy

Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

Most of the time, common skin flaws like skin tags or skin cysts are nothing more than unsightly and annoying, but occasionally there can be more to them. That’s why it’s important to know when you should have a doctor take a look at one.

Skin tags: Pesky but usually benign

Skin tags are flesh-colored skin growths that usually develop on areas of the body where skin rubs together, such as the neck, armpit or groin.

“They don’t discriminate — they affect people of all ages and body types and can occur anywhere, including the face,” says dermatologist Pamela Ng, MD.

Most of the time, skin tags are just an annoyance. “If it’s truly a skin tag, then it’s of no concern,” Dr. Ng says. “However, when skin tags are twisted, irritated, or bleeding, this might be a good reason to see a doctor.”

Why you shouldn’t remove a skin tag at home

With so many skin tag remedies on the market, can be tempting to try to remove one at home. You might even be considering one of those old-school skin tag home remedies like putting tea tree oil and a bandage on it or covering the skin tag with a piece of banana peel and then securing it with a bandage. Some people have even tried skin tag removal with apple cider vinegar or garlic.

But instead of treating your skin tag with fruit or salad dressing ingredients, Dr. Ng suggests leaving skin tag removal to the professionals.  She says that some home remedies can lead to skin irritation and even skin ulcers from application of home remedies such as apple cider vinegar.  And if you try to cut one off, it will only lead to bleeding and possibly an infection.

Advertising Policy

How a dermatologist can get rid of skin tags safely

Dr. Ng prefers to remove skin tags in-office by numbing the area and snipping off the tag. “I like the method of snipping best because it’s clean and the skin tags are gone by the time the patient leaves,” she says.

Other possible options for removing skin tags include:

  • Freezing, which will cause the tag to fall off after about 10-14 days, she says. However, freezing can cause greater inflammation to the surrounding skin.
  • Electrodessication, which is a surgical method of drying out tissue by touching it with a needle-like electrode that passes electric current into the tissue.

One thing to keep in mind, Dr. Ng says, is that skin tag removal is considered “cosmetic” by most insurance companies and usually is not covered.

Skin cysts: When in doubt, have them checked out

Skin cysts — called epidermoid cysts — are different from skin tags. They’re small nodules that form under the skin and fill with keratin, a structural protein found in the skin. Cysts can develop on various parts of the body, including the scalp.

Usually they’re nothing to worry about and don’t need to be removed unless they’re bothering you. But if one becomes inflamed, infected, or painful, Dr. Ng recommends getting it checked out by a doctor, as there are various tumors that can occur as lumps underneath the skin.

And if you have a skin tag on your eyelid, don’t be alarmed. Even though it’s in an awkward place, Dr. Ng says it can be removed.

“Skin tags on the eyelids can be tricky to remove due to the location, but they can be safely removed in most instances as long as patients remain calm during the procedure.”

Advertising Policy

The don’t-try-it-at-home advice holds true for removing skin cysts, too.

“Trying to take care of it on your own means you’re self-diagnosing,” she says. “You might be treating something inappropriate, like a skin cancer or a mole. Let a doctor diagnose it before you try anything at home.”

A doctor can make the cyst smaller and less inflamed or painful by injecting it with a steroid, which is sometimes mixed with an antibiotic. “I prefer this because it can decrease the swelling and pain without creating a scar or wound,” Dr. Ng says.

Sometimes, cysts have to be opened up and drained. This will leave a scar and the cyst can come back. Finally, cysts can be cut out surgically, but that will also be trading a bump for a scar.

If there’s ever any question about what’s going on with your skin, there’s no harm in having your doctor take a look, Dr. Ng says: “It’s best to have it evaluated by a physician if you are not sure what it is.”

Advertising Policy