January 28, 2018

Cough Syrup, Cough Drops, Menthol Rub: What’s Best?

The Short Answer from a family medicine physician

Medicine cup filled with cough syrup next to cough medicine and nearly finished packet of lozenges

Q: Is it best to buy cough syrup, cough drops or menthol rub?

A: A visit to the pharmacy reveals row after row of lozenges, syrups and other products for cough associated with wintertime virus. Most are helpful and reasonably safe.

Advertisement

Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

When choosing cough drops or rubs, keep in mind that “medicated” products aren’t truly medicated. They usually contain menthol, an aromatic substance that opens the airways to help reduce cough and congestion.

Cough syrups can contain any combination of these over-the-counter medicines:

  • Dextromethorphan, a very weak opiate, dulls the cough reflex.
  • Pseudoephedrine and related chemicals are decongestants. They decrease mucus production but can raise blood pressure and cause irritation from over-drying.
  • Guaifenesin, an expectorant, can loosen secretions. It’s generally the safest option.

(Parents should be aware that cough syrups and menthol rubs are not recommended for children. Cough lozenges and honey are fine after age 1.)

Advertisement

A couple of prescription medications can suppress cough: benzonatate (Tessalon Perles®) and promethazine cough syrup. Both are effective and non-narcotic.

But by far the simplest, safest treatment for cough and congestion is good hydration: drinking lots of fluids or rinsing the nasal passages with a saline solution.

— Family medicine physician Donald Ford, MD

Advertisement

Learn more about our editorial process.

Related Articles

child getting a cough medicine dose by spoon
October 29, 2023
Cough Medicine and Kids: Safety and Alternatives To Stop the Cough

Kids under 4 shouldn’t use cough and cold medicine — older kids may or may not benefit

Person with hand over mouth, coughing, with hand on their chest.
August 31, 2023
Can Essential Oils Treat a Cough?

A couple essential oils may be used with caution, but there are safer and more effective options

Person swims with flotation device in hands while doing laps at indoor pool.
August 13, 2023
Can Indoor Pools Cause Chlorine Cough?

Germ-killing chemicals in the water can lead to respiratory issues

While sitting on floor, parent wipes toddler's nose with tissue.
August 1, 2023
Does Your Kid Have Seasonal Allergies? How To Tell and How To Help

Sneezing, coughing and clear mucus shouldn’t be ignored

Person coughing in bed.
February 14, 2023
9 Ways To Stop Coughing at Night

Taking a warm shower before bed and drinking warm liquids throughout the day can help

Honey jars.
February 12, 2023
Honey for Your Sore Throat and Cough

The natural at-home remedy can soothe irritation and decrease inflammation

Baby coughing in white crib.
February 5, 2023
How To Care for Your Child’s Croupy Cough

Steam, cold air and extra snuggle time can help manage that seal pup bark

Person suffering from long covid.
September 29, 2022
Long COVID: Symptoms and Treatments for Long Haulers

Some may experience COVID-19 symptoms like fatigue for months or even a year after infection

Trending Topics

Person in yellow tshirt and blue jeans relaxing on green couch in living room reading texts on their phone.
Here’s How Many Calories You Naturally Burn in a Day

Your metabolism may torch 1,300 to 2,000 calories daily with no activity

person getting a sinus massage between brows
5 Sinus Massage Techniques To Relieve Pressure and Promote Drainage

A gentle touch in all the right places may help drain your sinuses

woman snacking on raisins and nuts
52 Foods High In Iron

Pump up your iron intake with foods like tuna, tofu and turkey

Ad