October 8, 2019

Is Red Meat Bad for Your Heart … or Not?

Don’t be confused by new reports

rare steak being prepped for grilling

For decades, scientific studies have shown a connection between eating red meat — like beef, pork, veal and lamb — and getting heart disease. That’s why the American Heart Association encourages limiting the amount of red meat you eat. (The right amount is different for everybody, but think deck-of-cards-size portions and not every day.)

Advertisement

Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

And many doctors, like Stanley Hazen, MD, PhD, Co-Section Head of Preventive Cardiology, recommend the Mediterranean diet, which allows little if any red meat.

However, new analysis published in the Annals of Internal Medicine questions everything we’ve believed about red meat.

Authors of these new reports say that evidence linking red meat to heart disease (and cancer and other diseases) is relatively weak. They say the data isn’t strong enough to make dietary recommendations. That has launched a barrage of news stories claiming that red meat has gotten a bad rap.

But take this news with a grain of salt. Don’t go restocking your freezer with steaks and burgers just yet. Dr. Hazen explains in this Q&A.

Q: Why has beef and other red meat been linked to heart disease?

Dr. Hazen: There have been innumerable studies — looking at hundreds of thousands of patients with millions of years of follow-up — that show a connection between eating red meat, getting heart disease and dying from heart disease. It’s remarkably consistent.

Exactly how red meat contributes to heart disease is debated. There probably are multiple reasons. Two likely contributors are the higher cholesterol and saturated fat content in red meat.

New data also points to choline and carnitine, other nutrients in red meat. Microbes in your gut break down these nutrients, generating TMAO (trimethylamine-N-oxide). High levels of TMAO in your blood increase your risk of hardened arteries, heart attack and stroke. There also may be other genetic or environmental factors, or a combination of factors, we haven’t uncovered yet.

Advertisement

Regardless, there is a connection. I totally disagree with the new reports that downplay past dietary studies. This is unfortunate and, I believe, irresponsible.

Q: Why do new reports in the Annals of Internal Medicine discredit earlier studies?

Dr. Hazen: Scientific studies come in different forms. Medical and research professionals view “prospective randomized trials” as the strongest and best quality. These trials randomly assign some participants to perform one set of behaviors and some to perform another.

Ideally, everything is the same except the single thing being tested. There are extremely few long-term randomized trials that have studied human diets with hard outcomes like heart attack, stroke and death. It’s hard to do because we humans are free-ranging animals. Studies like these would require controlling exactly what and how much a group of people eats day in and day out for many years.

For this reason, most diet studies are observational. They typically require people to fill out questionnaires about their eating habits. Researchers then analyze responses to determine risk of disease, for example, while adjusting for other factors (such as, “Do meat eaters exercise less? Do they eat more salt?”). This type of study isn’t as reliable as a randomized trial because people sometimes forget what they ate or miscalculate how much. But it still can give valuable information.

The authors who published the new reports in the Annals of Internal Medicine didn’t conduct a new trial. They instead reviewed previous studies and passed judgment on the quality of data. They determined that, because most studies on the health effects of eating red meat were observational, they’re not strong enough to guide dietary recommendations.

Q: Why do you disagree with them?

Dr. Hazen: Regardless of the type of study, research consistently shows that the more red meat you eat, the higher your long-term risk of getting and dying from cardiovascular disease. There is a clear association. And it’s been seen over and over in both men and women in various populations in various countries.

True, strictly speaking, we don’t know if the higher risk is caused by the red meat or associated factors (like the ketchup on the burger, the french fries on the side, eating meat instead of salad). But study after study has tried to adjust for these potential confounders. Just because these studies aren’t prospective randomized trials with hard outcomes doesn’t mean they should be ignored.

Advertisement

Q: Will there ever be a randomized dietary trial?

Dr. Hazen: Yes. There have been many, but they usually study things like weight, blood glucose or cholesterol. It would be very expensive and difficult to feed people a controlled diet for a decade or longer and count the heart attacks, for example.

The PREDIMED trial, published in 2013, is probably the closest we’ve come. It studied more than 7,000 people at a higher risk of heart disease. Each person was randomly assigned to one of three diets and followed for many years.

Researchers found that people eating a Mediterranean diet were 30-35% less likely to have a heart attack or stroke than people eating a standard low-fat diet. Notably, people following the Mediterranean diet in this study were urged to eat no red meat. However, the diet did include other protein sources — like fish and lean chicken — and plenty of vegetables, grains, some fruits, extra-virgin olive oil and nuts.

It’s true that instead of reduction in red meat, any one or more of these items could have contributed to the remarkable reduction in heart disease.

Q: Once and for all, what is your advice on eating red meat?

Dr. Hazen: According to most scientific studies, people who eat more red meat have a higher risk of heart disease. Even though I’m begrudgingly a meat lover, I advise people to reduce their heart risk by eating less red meat.

Related Articles

two kids eating snow outside
March 6, 2024
Is It Safe To Eat Snow?

If the flakes are undisturbed, pristine white and come from the top layer, it’s typically safe to indulge in a scoop

Small cup of yogurt with fresh blueberries on top, with mint sprig
March 1, 2024
Easy, Low-Calorie Snacks To Get You Through the Day

Snacking can bring benefits with healthy food choices and planning

Person enjoying container of assorted fruit
February 28, 2024
How To Protect Your Heart When You Have Prediabetes

You can counter the risk of prediabetes-related heart attack or stroke by eating more fruits, vegetables and whole grains, as well as exercising regularly

Cholesterol blocking blood flow in artery
February 26, 2024
What It Means if You Have ‘Sticky’ Cholesterol

LDL cholesterol and lipoprotein (a) cholesterol are more likely to stick to your arteries and lead to dangerous heart events

Doctor shaking hands with patient, with large heart and EKG line behind them
February 19, 2024
How Weight Affects Your Heart

Having underweight, having overweight and having obesity can be dangerous for your heart

Various cuts of red meat displayed
February 14, 2024
Is Red Meat Bad for You?

It has nutrients your body needs, but it also comes with some serious health risks

Close up of hands holding heart rate wearable watch monitor and their phone
February 12, 2024
Next Time You Exercise, Consider Wearing a Heart Rate Monitor

This technology can benefit your workouts by helping you hit your target heart rate, resulting in better overall health and wellness

seated doctor and female in doctor office, with female's hand on heart, with daughter
February 8, 2024
Here’s When You Should Go to the Hospital for a Dangerous Heart Rate

A resting heart rate below 35–40 beats per minute or over 100 beats per minute may be cause for concern

Trending Topics

White bowls full of pumpkin seeds, dark chocolate and various kinds of nuts
25 Magnesium-Rich Foods You Should Be Eating

A healthy diet can easily meet your body’s important demands for magnesium

Woman feeling for heart rate in neck on run outside, smartwatch and earbuds
Heart Rate Zones Explained

A super high heart rate means you’re burning more than fat

Spoonful of farro salad with tomato
What To Eat If You’ve Been Diagnosed With Prediabetes

Type 2 diabetes isn’t inevitable with these dietary changes

Ad