How One Doctor Addresses Doubts from Anti-Maskers

Talking points from a healthcare provider
woman wearing mask outside during pandemic

Masks have been at the center of a lot of debates these days.

Advertising Policy

Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

Some view them as lifesavers. Others view them as oppressive or suffocating. Regardless of how we all feel, studies have shown that masks can help keep us safe. The CDC has even stressed that cloth face coverings are critical in the fight against COVID-19 because they can reduce the spread of the disease, particularly when used universally within communities.

The evidence is very real — and so are the chances of you crossing paths with someone who simply refuses to wear a mask. So what do you say to a friend or family member who happens to be an anti-masker?

If you don’t know where to start, Aaron Hamilton, MD, offers his perspective and gives some solid talking points for those very awkward backyard conversations or social media exchanges. Dr. Hamilton has seen the damage that COVID-19 can do firsthand and strongly believes that healthcare providers should be good stewards of pandemic hygiene for their patients and the communities they serve.

Q: How do you respond to skeptics of COVID-19?

A: I try to center the conversation on my experience with the pandemic. We have patients with COVID-19 in our hospital and those who we are closely monitoring outside of the hospital. This is very real for the caregivers working on the frontlines with these patients. It’s very real for patients, and for the families of these patients. As caregivers, we have a close-up view of this pandemic, and it isn’t a political statement for us. It’s the reality of what many of us see when we come to work every day.

Advertising Policy

Q. What about those with “recommendation fatigue”?

A. Some people will say, “Well, the recommendations have changed 10 times. What am I supposed to believe?” And that’s a fair criticism, but it doesn’t change where we are right now. CDC guidelines reflect the information we have available, which has continued to evolve alongside what we’re learning about the virus.

Keep in mind, we didn’t have the benefit of learning about COVID-19 in medical school, during our residencies, or in our own clinical practice. No one has ever managed a COVID-19 pandemic before, and in many ways, we are learning about this together in real-time.

Q. How do you respond to parents who don’t think kids should have to wear masks?

A. A cloth mask isn’t appropriate for children under the age of two, and it may not be appropriate for children with respiratory or cognitive conditions. Aside from that, mask-wearing is something that parents can help socialize and normalize with kids.

I tell parents to start mask hygiene at home, just to get kids used to it. Parents should feel empowered to ask their kids about their feelings about going back to school and wearing a mask. While many school systems are implementing virtual learning programs, mask-wearing will be an important habit for when kids return to the classroom. Try to help them avoid complacency in the meantime. If you can avoid it, the classroom should not be the first time they’re putting on a mask.

Advertising Policy

Even with adults, some of it is just practice and getting comfortable with mask-wearing, like putting on a seat belt. The more you do it, the more you get used to it until it becomes second nature.

Q. Lastly, how do you respond to people who believe only medical-grade masks can help prevent transmission?

A. Where you are matters. Whether you’re at home, in the grocery store, or out in your community; a cloth mask is effective. When everyone wears masks, we’re all protected.

When you’re in a healthcare environment, some of those dynamics begin to shift. Smaller spaces and vulnerable populations create greater risk, and therefore, we shift towards procedural or medical-grade masks in those settings.

Of course, this is not new information for caregivers. But it might take a conversation with our patients and/or community members to help them understand the implications of risk and face coverings in a healthcare setting.

Advertising Policy